Data Organization

One of the things that bothers me about the standard computer desktop paradigm is that objects (files and such) only appear in one place. This fits in very well with the idea of a physical desktop — a paper document only exists in one place. If it needs to be in two places at once, a photocopy will do.

I often want to organize my files into categories. For example: I take a screenshot of a game that I am playing. Where do I store the file? My current convention is to follow my hierarchical folder structure down until the file fits: The screenshot is an image, so it goes in my “/images” directory. It is a screenshot, so it also goes in the  screenshots directory (“/images/screenshots”). It is from game ABC, so it also goes in the ABC directory (“/images/screenshots/ABC”). This is fairly straightforward so far. However, how do I categorize it now? It’s a really cool screenshot of my character (I have a “/images/screenshots/ABC/character_shots” directory) but it also has a good capture of the in-game weather (I also have a “/images/screenshots/ABC/weather” directory). There’s no real clear answer to this if we stick with the standard paradigm.

What I really want to do is tag or categorize this file. My quick initial pass at tagging results in these tags:

  • image
  • screenshot
  • game screenshot
  • ABC
  • character
  • weather
  • rain

This becomes even more important when I want to look for files. The standard file hierarchy I have set up now won’t help me much if I’m looking for all game weather screenshots.

I know there are image galleries that will provide some of this functionality, and I’m sure that there are file systems or explorer applications that will do the same for all types of files. (And I read that Vista was supposed to include something like this with the new file system, but this was cut, which was a shame. That was one of the major things I was looking forward to with Vista) Even so, the vast majority of users are still using the old paradigm, or even some other paradigm that doesn’t really fit — I’m sure you all know people who save their Word documents to whatever default location Word chooses.

Tags: , ,

4 Responses to “Data Organization”

  1. WC says:

    Actually Vista didn’t cut this. It’d just not that obvious on first inspection. If you enter the windows explorer (win+e, etc.). If you select a file on the bottom of the scree you’ll see a listing of properties. ‘Tags’ is among them. You can also add a column to the explorer window that includes those tags. Allowing you to directly view them. These tags are indexed by the vista indexing system for quick searches as well, allowing you to create virtual folder views. 😉

    A good article mentioning some of the features NTFS has had for years and were finally implemented in VISTA:

  2. Luisinho says:

    Од 22 November, 2012 – 7:24 pmyou’re really a good wbamester. The site loading speed is incredible. It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you’ve done a magnificent job on this topic!

  3. The “Quilt Police” have no power, unless you give it to them. I am a traditional quilter – but I like to change things up and have been the bane of many Quilt Police wanna bee’s. So when “they” say its wrong, you can’t do it that way, just reply: yes I can – as you can see I did. Love the pillow!

  4. sølv er altid en sikker vinder, så måske brude jeg prøve den guld fra DKNY, hvor er det ur dig klassisk og stilren. Forresten, tak for en cool blog!

Leave a Reply